About half way through reading “The Romantic Rationalist” I came across an article that listed several factors that the article’s author believed led to the conclusion that C.S. Lewis was “a wolf in sheep’s clothing.” “Romantic Rationalist” had already piqued my interest in Lewis’ weaknesses, and I respected and appreciated that its authors were not afraid to address the bad along with the good. However, thanks in part to the critical article and a comment from my father, I finished the book unsatisfied. Only one issue brought up in the article I read was addressed (and thoroughly, at that) by the book.
“Romantic Rationalist” was written by a group of authors (John
Piper, Randy Alcorn and more) for a conference on C.S. Lewis. The authors have different
styles of writing, but for the most part the book is well laid out and written.
The only chapter that gave me any trouble was a difficult-to-follow chapter on
salvation with confusing points on Calvinism. The chapters only graze the
surface of Lewis’ writings, which means, once again, I’m left with a desire for
deeper exploration. Other topics included Biblical Inerrancy (which Lewis did
not wholly support), Imagination (and its compatibility with reason), the
problem of evil, a good and sanctified creation, and Hell. Overall, it’s a very
quick, easy and short read that honors C.S. Lewis and his place in the authors’
*Disclaimer: I received this book for free in exchange for my honest review.